Skip to main content

Low Back Chiropractic Adjustments Had No Impact on Exercise: Questions Remain on Athletic Performance

 I tend to stay away from issues that claim chiropractic has any benefit besides simple musculoskeletal issues outside what is commonly accepted by the medical community. I am fascinated by intellectual issues, because I am always trying to learn new things and go beyond what is understood out there. There would be no progress made if no one questioned the mainstream ideology or thought outside the box. One has to choose carefully with so many health fads and myths out there. Here is a case that looks at chiropractic adjustments and exercise which is musculoskeletally related. It contradicts some "questionable" chiropractic research which I could not find. The research is not anti-chiropractic but it seems unbiased.
Abstract: This was a single-blinded, randomized, controlled trial of the immediate impact mid-lumbar spine CMT had on exercise science measures during a Bruce treadmill test at Texas Chiropractic College.
Translated, it means that the subject did not know whether or not he had a chiropractic adjustment before exercising on a treadmill.

Results There was no statistically significant difference between participants in the CMT group vs. the no-CMT group at baseline for heart rate, BL, or RPE. There was no statistically significant difference found in response to CMT for any exercise science measure throughout the GXT (Tables 2-5). This preliminarily indicates that lumbar spine CMT appears to have minimal impact on exercise science measures among asymptomatic chiropractic student participants. However, BLC was shown to be lower in the CMT group compared to the no-CMT group at maximal exertion (15.78 mmol/l, compared to 17.72 mmol/l). Effect size was not calculated due to the lack of statistical significance of study-dependent variables.  
The only change that was found was in blood lactate concentration (BLC), but no significant change was found otherwise. Another similar study was performed earlier but on a higher spinal level which found no effect. I am not sure why T12 and now L3 was targeted specifically. The study briefly mentioned adrenal glands which is L2 and lumbar plexus nerves. There is an old school of thought that believes in a spinal level that corresponds to specific organs called The Meric System. Here is the wikipedia for the nerve at the third lumbar segment and the nerves for the heart. There was one study that had mixed results on chiropractic adjustments and heart rate for testing of autonomic function. The subjects in the study were already healthy and young. I am not sure if they would find an effect assuming this is the right level to adjust for an effect on the treadmill exercise. One guess to why there might have been an effect on lactate levels is that the L3 nerve does innervate hip or leg muscles. The guess would be the effect on maximal innervation potential of these muscles. This is just an interesting theory but hard to say with such a small sample. I question whether minor joint misalignments or common chiropractic subluxations have a noticable effect on the nerve. Some say that the pressure as small as the weight of a dime has an effect but I can put light pressure on my wrist or carpal tunnel and the finger muscles seem fine in a practical sense. I will admit that there may be a small 10-20% effect on nerve innervation to a muscle. The real question is if the right chiropractic adjustments can give a small edge which professional athletes strive for. In a practical sense, the study results say no but the small result on BLC raises some questions for future research and athletic performance.



ChiroWorks Care Center
Anthony Tsai, D.C.
Chiropractor in San Jose, CA
Graston Technique Certified
FAKTR Certified

Disclaimer: The content in this blog is for informational purposes only and an opinion for specific individualized circumstances. It is not a prescription for therapy or diagnosis for you. All opinions expressed and any referenced articles are solely those of the particular author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Anthony Tsai, Graston Technique®, its employees, providers or affiliates. Any opinions of the author on the site are or have been rendered based on scientific facts and/or anecdotal evidence, under certain conditions, and subject to certain assumptions, and may not and should not be used or relied upon for any other purpose, including but not limited to for use in or in connection with any legal proceeding. If there is any issue with the content or images on this blog, contact us an we will remove it immediately. Please refer to http://fairuse.stanford.edu/Copyright_and_Fair_Use_Overview/ for more information.

References:
https://www.acatoday.org/JacaDisplay1.cfm?CID=5221&DisType=Textd
http://www.journalchiromed.com/article/S1556-3707(12)00124-1/abstract
http://www.dcorthoacademy.com/journal/journal_11/dec_11/research_dec11.php
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumbar_spinal_nerve_3
http://www.chirobase.org/05RB/BCC/11g.html
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1923077-overview

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kerri Walsh endorses KT Tape; SpiderTech Another Pre-cut Tape Brand

Some patients mentioned a precut elastic tape but now I have found what they were talking about. I am still not sure what was the exact brand used in the Beijing summer olympics but it looks like a new brand of kinesiology tape, KT Tape, is being endorsed by Kerri Walsh. The earliest press release that I can find is in May and June 2009. Oct 24, 2009, Mary Sheddon of The Tamba Tribune reports that KT Tape helps with foot pains and shin splints.SpiderTech is another brand claimed to be the "original" starting in 1987. Kinesio Tex developed by Dr. Kenzo Kase around 1984 according to their website also claiming to be the original. My guess is that Nitto Denko is a company that had a elastic sports tape since the 80's along with Kinesio Tex but Dr. Kenzo Kase developed an actual taping technique. Kinesio Tex has had several books and seminars for years. I have yet to find any book or seminar from SpiderTech or KT Tape. The earliest press release or product for SpiderTech tha…

"No Crack" Chiropractic With Mild Scoliosis And Posture Changes: Before and After X-rays

Before Chiropractic Treatments:
Small S-Shaped Curves.
9° Cobb Angle = Mild Scoliosis

After Chiropractic Treatments: On & Off over 4 yrs, Dramatic Reduction**Before Chiropractic Treatments:
Excessive Low Back Curve (Swayback or Anterior Pelvic Tilt)

After Chiropractic Treatments: On & Off over 4 yrs, Normal Low Back CurvatureBefore Chiropractic Treatments: Abnormal Neck Curve (Reverse Cervical Lordosis)

After Chiropractic Treatments: Reduction in Abnormal Cervical Curve. Neck pain was not regularly treated like the low back.
Can chiropractic adjustments fix scoliosis? That is the topic that I would like to put in the open. I would also like to show how chiropractic adjustments can be made without the cracking noises and still be effective. Here is another old blog post with low force chiropractic on scoliosis without after treatment x-rays. Officially, the American Chiropractic Association and probably other professional associations have the similar view that chiropractic care c…

London Olympics 2012: Kinesiotape / Kinesiology Tape / Physio Tape Skepticism Answered

Kinesiotape, aka kinesiology tape, physio tape or elastic therapeutic tape, is back in the Olympics in 2012. I made a blog article talking about the use of kinesiotape in 2008 with pictures of Kerri Walsh Jennings and Martin Plavins. For this olympics, it is used more than before but it is still not accepted by the skeptics in the scientific community. The critics credit any success to the placebo effect because of the lack of scientific evidence. There are plenty of journal research on professional athletes and superstition. Superstition gives athletes confidence which is proven to provide more "luck" or success. I will talk more about how kinesiotape does have specific therapeutic functions that are easy to understand.

"I think, if anything, there is a placebo effect involved, and there probably is a little bit of a peer pressure effect. When people see athletes who are doing so well, they think, 'Maybe this could work for me,'"
Dr. Nicholas Fletcher, an…